2026 Thanksgiving Cookie Boxes

These are the recipes I’m using to make my 2026 Thanksgiving cookie boxes! I love how this assortment is coming together with warm fall colors, cozy flavors, and lots of cute seasonal shapes.

I packed them in 10×10-inch boxes, which I ordered on Amazon.

image of chelsweets 2026 thanksgiving cookie boxes

For more details about planning your baking timeline, keeping cookies fresh, and packing or shipping cookie boxes, check out my original Christmas cookie box post.

1. Buttercream Turkeys

I always feel like I have to include some type of turkey treat in my Thanksgiving cookie boxes, and these adorable little turkeys are made with my buttercream cookie recipe and these 2-inch flower cookie cutters.

I used my candy eyes to make the face, but you can use store-bought eyeball sprinkles too!

image of buttercream turkey cookies

2. Gingham Shortbread Cookies

These gingham shortbread cookies are buttery, tender, and add such a pretty pattern to the box! The plaid design is perfect for fall and makes these cookie boxes feel so cozy.

image of gingham shortbread cookies that've been made for a thanksgiving box

3. Reese’s Acorns

These cute little acorns are inspired by Reese’s peanut butter cups! I used my peanut butter hearts recipe, but rolled the peanut butter mixture out to be about 1/4 of an inch thick, and dipped them in melted and cooled dark chocolate.

I also added a little extra drizzle of dark chocolate and a flaky sea salt garnish.

They’re a great addition if you want something chocolatey in your cookie box, and they give these boxes the perfect fall vibe. I used this cookie cutter to make them.

image of reeses inspired peanut butter and chocolate acorns

4. Pumpkin Oatmeal Sandwich Cookies

These pumpkin oatmeal sandwich cookies bring a delicious mix of warm fall spices and a soft, chewy texture to the box! And their brown butter cream cheese frosting makes them truly irresistible.

image of pumpkin oatmeal sandwich cookies that've been made for a thanksgiving cookie box

5. Pumpkin Spice Meringues

These little pumpkin spice meringues add the cutest pop of color to the box! They’re light, crisp, and a fun contrast to the buttery shortbread and chewy oatmeal cookies.

I used my go-to meringue cookie recipe, but piped them into little pumpkins for Thanksgiving and mixed in 1 tsp of pumpkin spice with the gel food coloring.

To make them, use gel food coloring to color about 1/2 cup of meringue green, then divide the remaining meringue in half. Leave one portion white and color the other orange to make two different shades of pumpkins.

I used a large French piping tip for the pumpkins and a leaf tip for the leaves.

image of pumpkin spice meringues being piped

6. Marbled Maple Leaf Cookies

Last but not least are these marbled maple leaf cookies! The swirled colors make each cookie a little different and bring all the beautiful shades of fall into this box.

They’re made using my cream cheese cookie dough base (which is what I use to make my buttercream cookies), which I divided into four portions and colored red, orange, yellow, and green with gel food coloring.

I tore the dough into small portions, then marbled the colors together by kneading the dough with my hands. I used this cookie cutter to give them that cute maple leaf shape. These turned out to be quite large, and using a smaller leaf cookie cutter would work great too.

image of marbled maple leaf cookies that've been made as part of a thanksgiving cookie box

Let Me Know What You Think!

I hope this year’s Thanksgiving cookie box inspires you to make your own! If you have any questions, feel free to leave a comment below. Happy baking!

Other Recipes You Might Like:

15 Comments

  1. I am wanting to order the Thanksgiving cookie box. Please I will send the money and write a great review, l

    1. Hi Teresa,

      Sadly I don’t sell or ship these boxes, I just make them for my friends and family! But I do share all the recipes if you want to make any of them. Hope that helps, happy baking!

  2. Hi! I think your sandwich cookies link to the wrong recipe. The recipe they link to is to maple oatmeal cookies. Are these the same cookie base? If so can you provide more details on the inside frosting? Thanks!

    1. Hi Samantha,

      You are so right, I am so sorry about that!! Postpartum brain fog is definitely still taking its toll on me. I’ve corrected the link to go to oatmeal sandwich cookies. Thanks for letting me know!

  3. The cookies from thr pumpkin sandwich cookie link are delicious, but they have sma brown butter icing instead of a creamy filling? Is it supposed to be a different cookie? What should the filling be?

    1. Hi Jessica,

      I am so sorry for the confusion! They are my oatmeal sandwich cookies (that’re made with pumpkin), I just updated the link! It was accidentally linking my maple oatmeal cookies. Thank you for letting me know!

    1. Hi Cathy,

      I usually make the cookies fully and then freeze them over a couple weeks, they all freeze well! But I make the meringue the day of because they can get kind of soft/sticky over time.

      Once the boxes are assembled, I try to give them to people the day of and let people know that the filled/buttercream cookies should be eaten first or stored in the fridge after a day. Hope that helps, happy baking!!

  4. Hi, Chelsea! I absolutely LOVE your cookie boxes so much! They are just beautiful! ? I’m making enough to fill 2 boxes worth and making mini cookies as a fill in. Thanks so much for sharing your recipes! Do you have any recipes to make a Hanukkah box?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *