2025 Thanksgiving Cookie Boxes

ByChelsey White

These are the recipes I used to make my 2025 Thanksgiving cookie boxes. They’re just as cute as they are delicious!!

These are the 10-inch boxes I used to make them, and I line them with a sheet of parchment paper to prevent any oil from seeping through the bottom.

For more details about planning, managing your baking timeline, how to keep cookies fresh, and how to pack/ship them, check out my original Christmas cookie box post from last year.

image of a cute thanksgiving cookie box that's been made with turkey meringues, acorn cookies, brownie pine cones, pumpkin pie sugar cookies, maple leaf cookies, and gingerbread sandwich cookies

1. Pumpkin Pie Sugar Cookies

These pumpkin pie sugar cookies are flavored with pumpkin spice and decorated to look just like a cute little slice of pumpkin pie.

image of cute pumpkin pie sugar cookies

2. Pine Cone Brownies

These pine cone brownies are such a fun, whimsical Fall dessert! The brownie centers are soft and fudgy, and they have an amazing crunch thanks to the chocolate cereal.

image of a pine cone brownie that's been made with chocolate cereal and dusted with powdered sugar

3. Turkey Meringues

These adorable little meringue turkeys are the perfect Thanksgiving treat! They’re light, airy, and perfectly crunchy with chewy centers.

image of an adorable meringue turkey that's been made for Thanksgiving

4. Acorn Cookies

These acorn cookies are naturally colored with cocoa powder and bake up deliciously soft and chewy.

image of cute acorn cookies that have baked on a metal pan

5. Maple Leaf Cookies

These maple leaf cookies bake up tender and buttery with a perfectly sweet, creamy maple buttercream filling.

image of maple leaf cookies that have been dipped in marbled royal icing to look like Fall leaves

6. Gingerbread Sandwich Cookies

These are a personal favorite of mine, so I try to sneak them into as many cookie boxes as I can! The texture and flavor are just so cozy and perfect for the colder months!

Let Me Know What You Think!

I hope you have as much fun with your holiday baking as I have this year! If you have any questions, feel free to leave a comment below. Happy baking!

37 Comments

  1. Pingback: Maple Leaf Cookies: Delicious Little Sandwich Cookies

    1. Hi Ireland,

      All of these can be frozen except for the meringue! Those need to be stored at room temp in an airtight container.

      I freeze the other cookies in airtight containers, then set the containers out a few hours before I plan to assemble the boxes. This usually gives them enough time to thaw to room temperature.

      The only note I do have is about the pumpkin pie sugar cookies! Those I pull out the night before and leave on the counter to thaw for longer. This helps prevent the royal icing from bleeding. As long as the cookies are able to full come to room temperature before you open the container, you should be able to prevent that. Hope that helps, happy baking!

      Reply

  18. Your desserts are work of art…please tell me they are available to purchase! Would love to surprise my granddaughter and buy a box and share them ?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *