Brooklyn Blackout Cake

Few things can beat a good chocolate cake. I’d heard of Brooklyn Blackout Cake before, but I figured it was just a really over the top chocolate cake.

I had no clue it involved pudding, cake crumbs, and that the name in no way relates the chocolate in the cake!!

The History Behind The Name

Here’s a brief snippet of history behind the name of this cake! This cake concept was developed by the Ebinger Baking Company during World War II.

Civilian black out drills were being practiced in Brooklyn to ensure that light from the city wasn’t reflecting on US ships off the coast, giving away their position.

Ebinger got creative with their marketing and named their cake after these drills. Their cake was filled with pudding, covered in a fudge frosting, and coated with cake crumbs!!

To honor the original cake concept, I’ve made this with chocolate cake layers (soaked in chocolate simple syrup), filled with a chocolate pudding, and covered in a milk chocolate ganache.

I used a few of my favorite recipes, along with some new recipes to create this cake. This was my first time making pudding from scratch, and I tried a few recipes before I found one I was happy with.

I highly recommend making it yourself, but if you’re short on time, you can always substitute in boxed pudding.

Brooklyn Chocolate Cake Recipes:

  • 1 batch my go-to chocolate layer cake recipe
  • 1 cup chocolate simple syrup (1 cup of water and 1 cup of sugar dissolved together, + 3 TBSP cocoa)
  • 1 batch chocolate pudding
  • 1 batch milk chocolate ganache (650 grams milk chocolate, melted down with 217 grams heavy cream) – to be made in advance
  • 1 cup chocolate frosting (1 cup American buttercream plus 2 Tbsp cocoa, and 2 additional tsp heavy cream)

Chocolate Ganache

Make the milk chocolate ganache first, as it needs at least a few hours to cool and set.

To make, simply place both the chocolate and heavy cream in a heat proof bowl, and heat it for 30 second increments (stirring between).

Usually after about 2 minutes of heat, all the chocolate is melted.

Once the mixture is fully incorporated, place plastic wrap over the top of the ganache, and let it sit at room temperature.

Before adding the room temperature ganache to a cake, I give it a slow stir with a spatula.

Chocolate Simple Syrup

I also recommend making the chocolate simple syrup in advance.

It needs time to cool before it can be used, and preparing it ahead of time makes the following day a  bit easier.

Place the sugar and water in a pot, and bring to a simmer. Once the sugar has dissolved, mix in the cocoa, and turn  off the heat. Pout into a sealed Tupperware container in the fridge overnight.

Bake 4, 7-inch round cake layers using my chocolate cake recipe and instructions.

Allow layers to cool fully before leveling. Place pans into the freezer for 1 hour, to accelerate the cooling process, and lock in the moisture.

Chocolate Pudding

While the layers bake, make the chocolate pudding.

Combine the sugar, cocoa, cornstarch and salt in medium saucepan; slowly mix in the milk. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly. Bring the mixture to a boil, and continue stirring for 1 minute.

Remove the pan from heat, and stir in the butter and vanilla. Pour the pudding into a separate bowl, and press plastic wrap directly onto surface to prevent a skin from forming. Place in the fridge to cool.

After the cake layers are baked and fully cooled, level the cakes by cutting off the tops using a serrated knife.

Place cake tops in a large bowl, and crumb using a fork. Set aside. Use a large, sterile paint brush to douse the cake layers with a generous coat of chocolate simple syrup.

Assemble the Cake

Next, it’s time to assemble the cake! Place the ganache into a piping bag, and pipe a ring around the perimeter of the cake layer.

blackout ganache boarded piping

Scoop about 3/4 of a cup of pudding into the center of the cake layer, and use an offset spatula to evenly spread it out to the ganache border.

blacout image pudding spread

Repeat this process with the remaining cake layers.

Once stacked, cover the cake with a thick layer of chocolate ganache, and smooth with a bench scraper.

Place chocolate cake crumbs around the base of the cake.

blackout crumbs around base

Use a large frosting tip (I used an Ateco 869) to pipe a border of chocolate frosting around the top of the cak. Then fill the center with additional cake crumbs.

blackout piping frosting on top

Then cut in and enjoy! This cake was DELICIOUS! I brought in the leftovers for my coworkers, and they couldn’t get enough of it 🙂

blackout slice

People are still talking about this cake, and ask me all the time when I’m going to make it again!

brooklyn blackout cake uncut

Let Me Know What You Think

If you try this Brooklyn blackout cake recipe, let me know what you think in the comments section. You can also tag me @chelsweets or use the #chelsweets so that I can see your amazing creations!

26 thoughts on “Brooklyn Blackout Cake

  1. Hey Chelsea! Just out of curiosity how long did you bake your cake layers? I totally trust Yo, but 50 minutes for 7in rounds seems like a long time. Am I misreading her instructions?

      1. Hi chelsey? sorry I would never disturb u again but plzz unblock me from instagram.
        And your this blackout cake is very amazing, after chocolate cups I will definitely try thisi

  2. Hello, the cake looks amazing!
    I just have one question; could I use normal dark cocoa (for baking) instead of Hershey’s in the pudding recipe? And how much milk should I use in the pudding recipe? 2 and 1/4 of glass? The recipe says 2 – 1/4 (so 1 and 3/4 glass then?)

    Best regards 🙂

  3. Oh and since we don’t have heavy cream in the UK, is better to use double cream (which contains more % of fat) or whipping cream (which contains less % of fat than heavy cream)?


  4. If I make this cake the day before and place it in the fridge overnight to stay cool, will it still be as moist and delicious?

    1. As long as it’s covered fully in buttercream, the frosting will lock in all the moister and deliciousness! I almost always make my cakes in advance, and refrigerate them overnight 🙂

  5. Hi Chels! I was wondering how I would make this differently with 8 inch pans, I have no 7 inch pans and I can’t find them anywhere! Help!

  6. Hello! I was just about to make this cake, was writing down all ingredients that I’ll need and I’ve noticed that the chocolate pudding recipe from Hershey’s website is gone :/ there’s an error every time I tried to open it (even if I type it in Google)…

    Could you write down the recipe for the chocolate pudding if possible?
    I’d really appreciate it!

      1. Thank you for the website but, unfortunately I can’t see the recipe; when I click on the link the website shows:
        ”Thank you for your interest in our brands.
        Though Hershey brands are loved worldwide, the site you are attempting to view does not support EU/EEA sales at this time. You will be redirected to our corporate site, which provides information about the company, our products, CSR initiatives and investor information. ”

        Could you please post the recipe in the comment for the chocolate pudding? I made it once and it was lovely but I don’t remember it exactly…

        I would really appreciate it!
        Best regards

  7. Hey Chelsey the cake looks fabulous.. A sponge recipe Ive been looking for quite some time now.. Can’t wait to try this… Would it be possible to get the recipe in metric measuremrnts as the cup measures we get are not accurate.

  8. Hi Chelsea, I was hoping to make this cake and cover the chocolate frosting with fondant. It will be 8inches which I have read above will be fine, maybe I’ll just need to alter the baking time. But I also wanted to add a 6in tier on top. Do you think this cake will work as the bottom tier?

    Thank you for your help!

    1. Hi Kristin,

      I added some chopped chocolate and cake crumbs, but mostly just for looks!! Haha It didn’t really add as much texture as I’d hoped it would :/

Let me know what you think!